This is relevant to any false claim and complicates things accordingly. What a person considers an argument should not be another person. In this sense, there is no correct or erroneous answer per se. In the law, there are always grey areas and it is a question of reconciling risks and benefits. Based on the fact that it looks like there is a claim, you may have misunderstood the advice of your local lawyer. One of the first steps you need to take before committing to the costs and risks of a dispute is to check if the proposed defendant has assets to pay a judgment that can be awarded to you by a court or an agreed settlement amount. .